---
title: "Year-end appeal letters for every donor on your list"
description: "Year-end appeal letters for every donor segment, a December email sequence, and the 2026 tax wording you can use, checked against the IRS."
canonical: https://gratefully.io/blog/year-end-appeal-letter-templates
category: "Fundraising Practice"
date_published: 2026-11-21
date_modified: 2026-11-21
read_time: "13 min read"
author: "Muddsar Jamil"
keywords: "year-end appeal letter"
source: Gratefully — Donor Intelligence for Nonprofits
---

# Year-end appeal letters for every donor on your list

## Quick answer

A year-end appeal asks supporters for a gift before December 31. Send each group of donors its own letter: someone who gave last year but not this year needs different words from your monthly donor. Below are eight letters by donor type, a four-email December sequence, and the tax wording a 2026 letter can use.

[[lead-magnet]]

<details>

<summary>On this page</summary>

- [Quick answer](#quick-answer)
- [Why one letter isn’t enough](#why-one-letter-isnt-enough)
- [Pull four lists before you write](#pull-four-lists-before-you-write)
- [The eight letters](#the-eight-letters)
- [The December email sequence](#the-december-email-sequence)
- [Tax wording for 2026: what you can say](#tax-wording-for-2026-what-you-can-say)
- [What the 2025 data says about December](#what-the-2025-data-says-about-december)
- [Where Gratefully fits](#where-gratefully-fits)
- [Sources](#sources)
- [Frequently asked questions](#frequently-asked-questions)

</details>

## Why one letter isn’t enough

**A year-end appeal is the fundraising ask an organization sends in November and December, built around the December 31 deadline that ends the tax year for most donors.** It usually runs as a mailed letter plus a short series of emails, all pointing to one giving page.

Search for a year-end appeal letter and you’ll get one: a thank-you, a story, a goal, an ask, a P.S. It’s a good letter. The problem is that it’s written for a donor who doesn’t exist. On a real list, the person who gave $50 for the first time in March, the person who gave every year until 2023, and the person who already gives $25 a month all receive the same words, and at least two of them notice.

The letters below share one structure and change where it matters: the opening, what they’re thanked for, and how much they’re asked for.

## Pull four lists before you write

Every letter below starts from a list. Pull these four from your CRM before you write anything, and remove anyone who has asked not to be solicited.

<table>
<thead>
<tr><th>List</th><th>Who is on it</th><th>Letter</th></tr>
</thead>
<tbody>
<tr><td>Gave last year, not yet this year</td><td>Any gift in the previous calendar year, none so far in this one. Often called LYBUNT (“last year but unfortunately not this”).</td><td>1</td></tr>
<tr><td>Already gave this year</td><td>At least one gift this calendar year. Split out first-time donors and monthly donors.</td><td>2, 3, 5</td></tr>
<tr><td>Lapsed two years or more</td><td>Gave in an earlier year, but nothing last year and nothing so far this year. Often called SYBUNT (“some year but unfortunately not this”).</td><td>4</td></tr>
<tr><td>Your largest donors</td><td>Whatever threshold your organization uses for mid-level and major gifts. These get a personal letter, and ideally a call first.</td><td>6</td></tr>
</tbody>
</table>

People who have never given, such as event guests, volunteers and newsletter readers, get letter 7. Letter 8 is a version of any of the others, used only when you have a real match.

For each donor on lists 1 to 4, note the last gift amount, its date, and what it funded. Those three facts become the opening of letters 1 to 4.

> **From Muddsar:** The list that’s easiest to skip is the second one, the people who already gave this year. If they get the same “will you give?” letter as everyone else, the first thing they read from you in December ignores the gift they already made. Pull them out first, even if all you change is the opening paragraph.

## The eight letters

Each letter has a “use when” line, an email subject line, and the letter. Bracketed text is yours to replace. Delete any bracket you can’t fill truthfully, and use only figures from your own records.

### 1. Gave last year, not yet this year

**Use when:** the donor gave in the previous calendar year and hasn’t given yet in this one.
**Email subject line:** [First name], will you stand with us again this year?

> Dear [First name],
>| Last year, your gift of $[amount] helped [specific outcome it funded]. I wanted you to know what happened next: [one sentence on where that work is now].
>| [Two or three sentences: one person, one moment from this year, and what changed for them.]
>| We’re working to raise $[goal] by December 31 to [what the goal funds next year]. Will you renew your gift of $[same amount as last year] before the year ends?
>| You can give at [short link], or return the enclosed card in the envelope provided.
>| Thank you for being part of last year. I hope you’ll be part of this one too.
>| [Signature]
>| [Name, title]
>| P.S. Gifts made by December 31 count toward this year’s goal. [Optional 2026 tax line from the tax wording section.]

**What makes it work:** it names the last gift and asks for the same amount again. Keep this letter about coming back, not about giving more; save upgrade asks for donors who have already given this year.

### 2. Already gave this year

**Use when:** the donor has already made a gift this calendar year (and isn’t a first-time or monthly donor, who get letters 3 and 5).
**Email subject line:** What your gift did this year, [First name]

> Dear [First name],
>| In [month], you gave $[amount] to [program]. Before I ask anything, I wanted to show you what it did: [specific result].
>| [Two or three sentences on one person or moment that gift was part of.]
>| Some supporters like to make one more gift before the year closes, and if that’s you, a gift of $[amount] would [specific outcome next year]. You can give at [short link].
>| If not, please know your gift this year already made a difference, and we’re grateful for it.
>| [Signature]
>| [Name, title]

**What makes it work:** the thank-you comes first and is complete on its own. The ask is optional by design. If your list is small, consider sending this group an impact update with no ask at all.

### 3. First-time donors from this year

**Use when:** the donor made their first ever gift this year.
**Email subject line:** [First name], here’s what your first gift started

> Dear [First name],
>| This year you gave to [Organization] for the first time, $[amount] toward [program]. Thank you. Here’s what it helped do: [specific result].
>| [One or two sentences on why continued support matters for the people you serve, with one specific example.]
>| Would you make a second gift of $[amount, no more than their first] before December 31? You can give at [short link].
>| Welcome to [Organization]. I’m glad you’re here.
>| [Signature]
>| [Name, title]
>| P.S. If you’d like to hear how the work goes before giving again, just reply and I’ll send you an update in [month].

**What makes it work:** it treats the first gift as the start of something and asks for a second one no bigger than the first. The P.S. gives a new donor a way to stay involved without giving again yet.

### 4. Lapsed two years or more

**Use when:** the donor gave in an earlier year, but not last year and not yet this year.
**Email subject line:** It’s been a while, [First name]

> Dear [First name],
>| In [year of last gift], you gave $[amount] to help [what it funded]. I don’t know what’s changed for you since then, but I wanted to tell you what’s changed here.
>| [Two or three sentences: what’s different or new about the work, with one specific example.]
>| If you’d like to be part of it again, a gift of $[amount, no more than their last gift] before December 31 would [specific outcome]. You can give at [short link].
>| Either way, thank you for what you did in [year]. It still mattered.
>| [Signature]
>| [Name, title]

**What makes it work:** it doesn’t pretend no time has passed, and it doesn’t guilt the reader. It asks for no more than the last gift, because the goal is the return. If a donor tells you why they stopped, record it.

### 5. Monthly donors

**Use when:** the donor gives by recurring monthly gift.
**Email subject line:** A year of your monthly gifts, [First name]

> Dear [First name],
>| Every month [this year / since [month you started]], your gift of $[monthly amount] arrived. That’s $[total given this year] in all, and it [specific outcome it supported].
>| [One or two sentences on what steady monthly support lets your team plan for.]
>| I’m not writing to ask for an extra gift. I’m writing to say thank you, and to let you know that if you’d ever like to raise your monthly gift, even by $[small amount], you can do it at [link to update recurring gift].
>| Thank you for being there every month.
>| [Signature]
>| [Name, title]

**What makes it work:** it thanks the donor for the year and states their total in one figure. The upgrade line is low-key. You can also leave monthly donors out of the year-end ask entirely; if you do ask, keep it this soft.

### 6. Mid-level and major donors

**Use when:** the donor is in your mid-level or major gift range. Call first if you can, then send this as a follow-up, signed by the executive director or board chair.
**Email subject line:** [First name], a note before the year ends

> Dear [First name],
>| [If you spoke: “Thank you for taking my call on [day].”] Your support of $[amount] this year [or last year] made [specific, significant outcome] possible, and I wanted to put on paper what that has meant.
>| [Three or four sentences: one specific story, and what your leadership donors made possible that wouldn’t have happened otherwise.]
>| As we plan for [next year], we’re looking to [specific goal or project, with its cost]. I’d like to ask you to consider a gift of $[amount] toward it before December 31. [If relevant: “I’ve enclosed a one-page summary of the plan.”]
>| I’d be glad to talk it through, or to show you the work in person. My direct line is [phone].
>| With thanks,
>| [Signature]
>| [Name, title]

**What makes it work:** it’s a letter from one person to another, not a campaign piece. It names a specific project and amount and offers a conversation. If the donor gives through a donor-advised fund or an IRA, make sure your giving instructions cover those routes.

### 7. People who have never given

**Use when:** the person knows you, as an event guest, volunteer or newsletter reader, but has never made a gift.
**Email subject line:** [First name], would you join us before the year ends?

> Dear [First name],
>| [How they know you: “Thank you for volunteering at [event] in [month].” / “You’ve been reading our newsletter since [year].”]
>| [Two or three sentences: one person or moment from this year that shows what the work does.]
>| This December, we’re raising $[goal] to [what it funds]. Would you make your first gift of $[amount] before December 31? It would [specific outcome].
>| You can give at [short link].
>| Thank you for being part of what we do already.
>| [Signature]
>| [Name, title]

**What makes it work:** it starts from what the person has already done, so the ask is about the next step in a relationship that exists. Ask for a modest amount tied to a concrete outcome.

### 8. Matching gift or challenge

**Use when:** a donor, foundation or business has committed in writing to match gifts dollar for dollar, up to a set amount, by a set date. Adapt any of the letters above with these lines. If the match is not dollar for dollar, change “doubled” and the doubled amount to fit the real terms.
**Email subject line:** Your gift doubled before December 31, [First name]

> [Add after the story paragraph:]
>| **Until December 31, [name of matching donor, or** **“a group of our supporters”** **if they prefer not to be named] will match every gift, up to a total of $[match cap].** That means your gift of $[amount] becomes $[double the amount] for [program].
>| [Add as the P.S.:]
>| P.S. We’ve raised $[amount so far] toward the $[match cap] match. Every gift until December 31 is matched until it’s reached.

**What makes it work:** a match gives the deadline a reason. Only say a gift is matched if the commitment is real, the terms are in writing, and you’ll report the result honestly. If the match fills early, say so in your next email.

## The December email sequence

Send the letter in November and follow it with emails in December. Keep GivingTuesday (the Tuesday after US Thanksgiving) as its own message, so it doesn’t crowd your year-end ask. After that, four short emails cover the last two weeks.

### Email 1: mid-December goal update

**Subject:** We’re [percentage]% of the way there

> Dear [First name], thanks to [number] supporters, we’ve raised $[amount] of our $[goal] goal for [what it funds]. We have until December 31 to close the gap. If you’ve been meaning to give, here’s the link: [short link]. Thank you. [Signature]

### Email 2: December 28 reminder

**Subject:** Four days left, [First name]

> Dear [First name], the year ends on [day], and we’re $[amount] from our goal. A gift of $[amount] would [specific outcome]. [Short link]. Thank you for everything this year. [Signature]

### Email 3: December 31, morning

**Subject:** Last day to give in [year]

> Dear [First name], today is the last day to make a gift in [year]. We’re $[amount] from our goal. [Short link]. Thank you. [Signature]

### Email 4: December 31, afternoon (only to people who haven’t given)

**Subject:** A few hours left

> [First name], one short note: there are a few hours left in [year], and we’re $[amount] away. [Short link]. [Signature]

Remove anyone who has given from the next email, and check the day of the week for December 31 in your own year before scheduling. In 2026, December 31 falls on a Thursday.

> **From Muddsar:** The last three days are where a stale list hurts most. If someone gave on the 29th and still gets “A few hours left” on the 31st, the email just told them you don’t know they gave. Suppress donors from the sequence daily in the last week, not weekly.

## Tax wording for 2026: what you can say

**From tax year 2026, people who don’t itemize their deductions may deduct up to $1,000 of qualifying cash gifts to eligible charities, or $2,000 for married couples filing jointly.** The IRS reminded taxpayers of this on November 10, 2026. It means a donor who takes the standard deduction may now be able to deduct a cash gift.

The rule has limits that matter for your letter. According to the IRS, the deduction applies only to cash gifts, not to gifts of goods or stock. Cash gifts to supporting organizations, or to set up or add to a donor-advised fund, don’t qualify.

Check your own status before you use the wording below. The deduction covers cash gifts to organizations described in section 170(b)(1)(A) of the tax code, which includes most public charities. If your organization is a supporting organization under section 509(a)(3), or isn’t described in section 170(b)(1)(A), gifts to you don’t qualify, and neither line below belongs in your letter. Your IRS determination letter states your public charity status.

**Wording you can use in a 2026 P.S.:**

> New this year: if you don’t itemize, you may be able to deduct up to $1,000 of cash gifts to charities like ours ($2,000 for married couples filing jointly). Please check with your tax adviser about your own situation.

Or, shorter:

> Gifts made by December 31 may be deductible on your 2026 taxes, even if you don’t itemize. Your tax adviser can tell you how this applies to you.

**What not to say:**

- **“Your gift is tax-deductible,”** **with nothing more.** Whether a donor can deduct a gift depends on their own return. “May be deductible” is accurate; “is deductible” may not be.

- **That a gift through a donor-advised fund counts toward the new deduction.** The IRS says cash gifts to set up or add to a donor-advised fund don’t qualify.

- **That a gift is fully deductible when the donor gets something back,** such as an event ticket. Gifts over $75 that are partly for goods or services need a written disclosure. Our [donation request letter guide](/blog/donation-request-letter-templates#compliance) covers the wording.

**When a December gift counts for the donor’s taxes,** per IRS Publication 526:

<table>
<thead>
<tr><th>How the donor gives</th><th>When it counts as made</th></tr>
</thead>
<tbody>
<tr><td>Check sent by mail</td><td>The date it is mailed</td></tr>
<tr><td>Credit card</td><td>The year the charge is made</td></tr>
<tr><td>Text-to-give charged to a phone bill</td><td>The year the text is sent</td></tr>
<tr><td>Stock certificate, endorsed and mailed to you</td><td>The date it is mailed or delivered to you. If sent to the donor’s broker or the company for transfer, the date the shares are transferred on the company’s books.</td></tr>
</tbody>
</table>

This is why “postmarked by December 31” works on a reply card for checks. For stock, ask donors to start transfers early in December, because the date that counts can be later than the day they send the instruction.

This is general information, not tax advice. Tax rules change, and how they apply depends on each donor’s situation.

## What the 2025 data says about December

You’ll often see a single figure for how much giving happens in December. The latest figures depend on what’s being measured:

- **Online giving:** nonprofits received 37% of all 2025 online revenue in December, according to the M+R Benchmarks 2026 study. The last week of the year accounted for 10% of annual online revenue, and the last day alone for 4%. M+R notes that GivingTuesday fell in December in 2025.

- **All giving:** the Blackbaud Institute’s 2025 Trends in Giving report found December accounted for about 18% of all giving, and the last quarter for 36.1% of annual revenue.

Both point the same way. December’s share is larger for online giving, and online, the last week carries a tenth of the year, which is why the sequence above puts three of its four emails in the final four days.

## Where Gratefully fits

The letters are the quick part. The slow part is the four lists, and then writing letter 1 for every donor on list one with their real last gift, date and program.

Gratefully sorts every donor into a living segment, such as Loyal, New, At-Risk, Lapsed or Dormant, from the recency, frequency and value of their giving, and refreshes it nightly. From any segment, Grace, the AI assistant inside Gratefully, can write an [individually personalized letter for each donor](/capabilities/outreach-letters), grounded in their real giving history and in your organization’s own voice, and you can download them as a CSV for a mail merge. Grace also won’t suggest asking a donor who has just given, the same care letter 2 takes by hand. Its Playbooks library includes year-end campaign prep. Nothing is sent without a person approving it.

Before you write letter 6, our free [Donor Relationship Health Audit](/donor-health-audit) is a 10-minute self-assessment of your top 20 donor relationships.

## Sources

- Internal Revenue Service, “IRS reminder: Permanent charitable contribution deduction begins for returns filed next year for taxpayers who do not itemize,” IR-2026-135, November 10, 2026: [https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-reminder-permanent-charitable-contribution-deduction-begins-for-returns-filed-next-year-for-taxpayers-who-do-not-itemize](https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-reminder-permanent-charitable-contribution-deduction-begins-for-returns-filed-next-year-for-taxpayers-who-do-not-itemize) (read 20 November 2026)

- Internal Revenue Service, “Topic no. 506, Charitable contributions”: [https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc506](https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc506) (read 20 November 2026)

- 26 U.S. Code § 170(p), “Special rule for taxpayers who do not elect to itemize deductions,” via Cornell Law School LII: [https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/170](https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/170) (read 20 November 2026)

- Internal Revenue Service, Publication 526, “Charitable Contributions,” section “When To Deduct”: [https://www.irs.gov/publications/p526](https://www.irs.gov/publications/p526) (read 20 November 2026)

- M+R, “Benchmarks 2026: Fundraising”: [https://mrbenchmarks.com/fundraising/](https://mrbenchmarks.com/fundraising/) (read 20 November 2026)

- Blackbaud Institute, “2025 Trends in Giving”: [https://institute.blackbaud.com/2025-trends-in-giving/](https://institute.blackbaud.com/2025-trends-in-giving/) (read 20 November 2026)

## Frequently asked questions

### When should I send a year-end appeal letter?

Mail in November and follow with emails in December, with the heaviest emailing in the last week. M+R’s 2025 data found the last week of the year brought in 10% of annual online revenue.

### What should a year-end appeal letter include?

A thank-you, one specific story, a goal with a December 31 deadline, a specific ask amount with what it will do, how to give, and a P.S. For past donors, mention their last gift, its date and what it funded.

### Should I send a year-end appeal to donors who already gave this year?

Yes, but with a different letter. Thank them for their gift and show what it did before any ask, and make the ask optional. Letter 2 above is written for them.

### Can non-itemizers deduct charitable donations in 2026?

Yes. From tax year 2026, people who don’t itemize may deduct up to $1,000 of qualifying cash gifts, or $2,000 for married couples filing jointly. Noncash gifts and cash gifts to donor-advised funds don’t qualify. Donors should check their own situation with a tax adviser.

### Does a check mailed on December 31 count for this year?

Under IRS Publication 526, a check mailed to a charity counts as delivered on the date it is mailed. That’s why reply cards often say “postmarked by December 31.”


---

Canonical HTML version: https://gratefully.io/blog/year-end-appeal-letter-templates
More about Gratefully: https://gratefully.io/ai-instructions
